Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl Odds, Season Predictions and Best NFL Futures Bets 2023


The 2022 season was a miserable one for the Indianapolis Colts. The Colts haven’t reached the same heights following the retirement of Andrew Luck, and it bottomed out last fall with an abysmal 4-12-1 season and a top 5 pick in the NFL Draft. Will the addition of Anthony Richardson give Indianapolis new life heading into the 2023 season, or will this year be just as terrible as the previous season as the Colts begin the long rebuilding process? Let’s take a look at some of the odds and best bets to be made on the Indianapolis Colts in 2023.

You can bet on this season’s NFL action over at DraftKings Sportsbook, which has a great sign-up offer where you can bet $5 and get $150 in bonus bets no matter what! Click here to take advantage and claim your bonus bets right now.

Indianapolis Colts breakdown

2022 record: 4-12-1

2022 ATS record: 6-11

2022 O/U record: 7-10

Key players in: Isaiah McKenzie (WR), Gardner Minshew (QB), Tony Brown (CB), Ashton Dulin (WR), Matt Gay (K).

Key players out: Bobby Okereke (LB), Parris Campbell (WR), Yannick Ngakoue (EDGE). 

2023 NFL Draft class: Anthony Richardson (QB), Julius Brents (CB), Josh Downs (WR), Blake Freeland (OT), Darius Rush (CB), Daniel Scott (S), Will Mallory (TE), Evan Hull (RB), Titus Leo (LB), Jaylon Jones (CB).

Head over to the Pickswise NFL futures betting guide for odds and predictions on various betting markets 

Indianapolis Colts 2023 NFL season odds

Odds provided by FanDuel Sportsbook 

Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl odds

At +10000, the Colts are not expected to be a Super Bowl contender by any conceivable metric. Indianapolis is projected to be one of the worst teams in football by the oddsmakers.

Indianapolis Colts AFC Championship odds

The Colts currently sit at +6500 to win the AFC. This puts them at 14th in the conference according to the oddsmakers.

Indianapolis Colts AFC South odds

The Colts are +550 to win the AFC South, putting their odds at third in the division behind the Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans.

Indianapolis Colts win total odds

The Colts win total is 4.5 games. Over 4.5 is at -118, while the under comes with -102 odds. 

All of today’s biggest games are available to bet with BetMGM, the premier destination for online sports betting. New customers can earn themselves a $1,000 deposit bonus by signing up right now! Click here to lock in this great sign-up offer.

Indianapolis Colts 2023 schedule

Week 1: vs Jacksonville Jaguars

Week 2: at Houston Texans

Week 3: at Baltimore Ravens

Week 4: vs Los Angeles Rams

Week 5: vs Tennessee Titans

Week 6: at Jacksonville Jaguars

Week 7: vs Cleveland Browns

Week 8: vs New Orleans Saints

Week 9: at Carolina Panthers

Week 10: at New England Patriots 

Week 11: BYE

Week 12: vs Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Week 13: at Tennessee Titans

Week 14: at Cincinnati Bengals

Week 15: vs Pittsburgh Steelers

Week 16: at Atlanta Falcons

Week 17: vs Las Vegas Raiders

Week 18: vs Houston Texans

We’ll have NFL picks for EVERY matchup of the 2023 season 

Indianapolis Colts 2022 NFL season recap

The Colts entered last season as too good of a team to tear it down, but nowhere near a contender in a loaded AFC filled with great quarterbacks across the board. This led into a season where Indianapolis was actually the AFC South favorite in September over the likes of Tennessee and Jacksonville. However, all it took was a couple of weeks to see that the Colts were not who most pundits thought they would be during Training Camp. After starting 3-2-1, Indianapolis dropped 10 of its next 11 games and ended up with the #4 pick in the NFL Draft. It marked the end of the Matt Ryan era as the Colts opted to go in a new direction at quarterback going forward.

Indianapolis Colts 2023 NFL season predictions

This is a fascinating team from a betting perspective because we don’t really have any idea what we’re going to get. The Colts are going to be implementing a brand new offense with rookie phenom Anthony Richardson now at the controls under center. Richardson is about as different a player stylistically as you can be from the likes of Matt Ryan, Carson Wentz and Phillip Rivers before him, which makes projecting Indianapolis’ season so compelling. This should be one of the worst teams in the AFC, but I still see some value on the Colts to slightly outpace their preseason expectations. 

Best bet: Indianapolis Colts over 4.5 wins (-118)

Before breaking into my numbers and research on this Colts team, I actually thought I was going to lean toward the under. But given how nicely the schedule shapes up at multiple junctures throughout the season and my belief in Richardson as a potential franchise-lifting quarterback down the road, it’s hard not to take the over at this number.

The fact of the matter is very few quarterbacks have ever come into the NFL with the physical profile of Richardson, if any. He should be put in a decent position to succeed in Shane Steichen’s offense, who just buoyed Jalen Hurts to a career-best season. Even if Richardson struggles in the passing game, read option plays with Jonathan Taylor in the backfield will be very hard to stop. If Richardson doesn’t pop this season, the win total might end up coming down to a Week 18 home game against the Texans, where I still think the Colts would be favored to pick up their 5th victory.

Indianapolis Colts season record prediction: 5-12

The biggest feather in Indianapolis’ cap is the schedule, with the Colts drawing the putrid NFC South in addition to their own weak division. Outside of Jacksonville, it’s not like the other 2 teams have clear and obvious talent advantages over Indy. It’s fair to expect the Colts to grab 2 wins in the division, and they’ll also get to host the Buccaneers, Raiders and Rams, while also traveling to Carolina and Atlanta. However, wins should be hard to come by the rest of the way, as 4 games against the AFC North should put this team to the test. Overall, I could see the Colts winning 6 or 7 games if things break their way, but I’ll opt for the safer option at 5-12.

All of today’s biggest games are available to bet with BetRivers, where you can secure up to $500 in bonus bets if your first wager loses. Click here to sign up for BetRivers now.


Pickswise is the home of free Expert NFL Picks and NFL Odds. Be sure to check out all of our season previews and NFL Futures Bets leading up to the 2023 NFL Season. 

PHP Code Snippets Powered By :